Google Ads vs SEO vs GEO: What Actually Drives Leads for NZ Businesses

Topics

Introduction

NZ businesses are being told they need Google Ads, SEO, and now GEO to grow. The problem is that most advice treats these channels as competing options, when in reality they solve different problems at different stages of growth.

This page breaks down what each channel actually does, where it works best in the NZ market, and how to decide which one should lead your strategy.

What Google Ads does best in the NZ market

Google Ads is the fastest way to generate demand from people who are already searching with intent. In NZ, where search volumes are smaller and competition varies by region, this immediacy matters.

Google Ads works best when:

  • You need leads or sales quickly
  • You are targeting high-intent keywords
  • You have a defined service or product with clear conversion points
  • You want predictable lead flow rather than long-term visibility

 

The downside is cost. Google Ads stops the moment spend stops, and poorly structured campaigns waste budget fast. Without proper tracking and ongoing optimisation, it becomes expensive noise.

Best for:
Service businesses, trades, clinics, professional services, and eCommerce brands that need consistent enquiries or sales now.

What SEO actually delivers over time

SEO focuses on long-term visibility rather than immediate demand. In NZ, SEO can be extremely effective for businesses willing to invest time into content, technical structure, and authority.

SEO works best when:

  • You want sustainable traffic without paying for every click
  • You operate in a niche where trust and comparison matter
  • You are building brand credibility over time
  • You can wait several months for results to compound

     

The trade-off is speed. SEO does not generate instant leads, and poorly targeted content can attract traffic that never converts.

Best for:
Established businesses, brands investing in long-term growth, and companies with multiple services or locations.

What GEO changes in how people discover businesses

GEO focuses on how your brand appears and is referenced inside AI-generated answers. This includes systems like Google AI Mode, ChatGPT, and other generative search experiences.

Unlike SEO, GEO is not about rankings. It is about whether your business is understood, trusted, and recommended when users ask AI questions like:

  • “Who should I hire for…”
  • “Is X worth it in NZ?”
  • “What’s the best option for…”

     

GEO works best when:

  • Buyers research before contacting
  • Services require explanation or comparison
  • Trust and positioning matter more than raw traffic
  • You want visibility beyond traditional search results

     

GEO does not replace SEO or Google Ads. It amplifies the brands that already communicate clearly.

Best for:
Professional services, agencies, high-ticket offerings, and businesses where decision-making happens before the click.

Google Ads vs SEO vs GEO: a practical comparison

Google Ads

  • Speed: Immediate
  • Cost model: Pay per click
  • Lead quality: High if structured well
  • Longevity: Stops when spend stops
  • Best role: Demand capture

     

SEO

  • Speed: Slow to start
  • Cost model: Time and content investment
  • Lead quality: Medium to high
  • Longevity: Compounds over time
  • Best role: Demand creation and trust

     

GEO

  • Speed: Medium
  • Cost model: Content and positioning
  • Lead quality: High for considered purchases
  • Longevity: Grows with authority
  • Best role: Decision influence and brand recommendation

     

Each channel solves a different problem. Treating them as interchangeable is where most strategies fall apart.

What actually drives leads for NZ businesses

For most NZ businesses, leads come from combining these channels, not choosing one.

A typical high-performing setup looks like this:

  • Google Ads captures immediate, high-intent searches
  • SEO builds visibility and trust for broader research queries
  • GEO ensures your brand is mentioned and recommended during AI-driven research

     

Businesses that rely on only one channel usually hit a ceiling. Those that align all three tend to see stronger lead quality and more consistent growth.

Which channel should you prioritise first?

Use this as a simple decision guide.

Start with Google Ads if:

  • You need leads quickly
  • You have a clear service offering
  • You can spend at least $1,000 per month

Start with SEO if:

  • You want long-term growth
  • You are building authority in a niche
  • You can invest consistently over time

Add GEO when:

  • Buyers compare options before contacting
  • You want visibility in AI-generated answers
  • You want to influence decisions, not just clicks

In practice, most growing NZ businesses benefit from running Google Ads while building SEO and GEO in parallel.

The mistake most NZ businesses make

The biggest mistake is chasing channels instead of outcomes.

Google Ads is blamed when tracking is wrong.
SEO is blamed when expectations are unrealistic.
GEO is dismissed because it is misunderstood.

The real issue is usually strategy, not the channel.

How Impacto approaches Google Ads, SEO, and GEO together

We don’t treat these channels as separate silos. Each one feeds the others.

  • Google Ads data informs SEO and GEO priorities
  • SEO content supports AI visibility and landing page performance
  • GEO clarifies positioning so paid and organic traffic converts better

This integrated approach is what allows campaigns to scale without wasting spend or relying on guesswork.

Which one will you choose?

If you’re not sure which channel should lead your strategy, we can review your current setup and give you a clear recommendation based on your goals, budget, and market.

STRATEGIC SEARCH GUIDANCE FOR NZ BUSINESSES

We help NZ businesses choose the right mix of Google Ads, SEO, and GEO; based on what will deliver results now, and what will compound over time.